Just came back from Burgundy. I tasted many 09s, which many Burgundians call too ripe, too international in taste. As a wine lover, I heartily disagree, putting such talk in the category of “we have trouble selling 08s and 07s and no problem selling 09s so let’s talk up the former” … But not always.
A serious discussion yesterday with Frederic Mugnier for example almost convinced me that he had a point, that the 08s have more cool climate Pinot Noir Purity than the 09s. In some cases, yes, I found myself preferring 08s to 09s. Take his Bonnes Mares 2008. Better than some Bonnes Mares 09s I had tried, which were a bit too heavy (in comparison), a bit too ripe for their own good(?), lacking some nuance and freshness.
But then, compare Mugnier’s Clos de la Marechale 09 with this Clos de la Marechale 08, and you can see why the 09 is better, and will likely age better. I will post detailed notes on my website very soon on these and other tastings, but all this to say that for all this talk of Burg 09s being a bit New World in style, such talk does not hold a candle to what is happening in parts of Bordeaux, where 15 to 15+ alcohol levels are making THOSE wines far more New World than any 09s from Burgundy.
And hence my big hugging of Burgundy… The Dark Side, my friends, is proving brighter, with greater freshness and, yes, nuance. Not always. And there is a certain apple and orange aspect to all this. How can you compare Cab to Pinot?`Or Merlot to Pinot? Well… you can. Subjectively speaking, you can. And as alcohol levels head ever higher, ever headier in parts of Bordeaux, I will opt for the Pinot. Still, I do love Bordeaux, do not get me wrong. There are Bordeaux estates that are brilliant and their wines cannot be beat. But it was great to be in Burgundy and discover also rather inexpensive wines that beat the crap out of some more expensive, more extracted, bigger and bolder New World like Bordeaux. Here but three examples (many more)…
Domaine Newman Pommard 2009, €25 ex cellar
Domane Mugneret Gibourg Vosne Romanee 2009, €25 ex cellar
Domaine Taupenot Merme Morey St Denis 2009, €25 ex cellar
All very fine, exhibiting ripe fruit, but freshness and nuance, and for the price, and availability, cannot be beat. Ok, I spent more money on more prestigious appellations, including €75 per bottle for Mugneret Gibourg Exchezeaux, but that bottle was floral, cherry pit, cassis purity, with 60% new oak oh so well integrated. An amazing wine, that for the price - reflecting genuine scarceness - is a better deal than some higher end Bordeaux that also cost even more money.
Welcome to Burgundy, the Dark Side can be brighter. And can be devilishly fun.