Wow, on a similar note my wife and I just had to throw out a liter of EVOO that seemed to have brett. Plasticy band aid smell and taste have no place in olive oil!
For those who aren’t sure what ‘corked’ smells like, I usually suggest getting a package of mini carrots from the store and notice the smell upon opening . . . and the same is often the case with prepacked apple slices.
I recall reading about the corked baby carrots in the epicurian forum. Someone seemed to think it had something to do with the chemicals they wash them in. Maybe your potatoes saw a chemical rinse as well. I have no clue what ruined my olive oil.
So you read the Asimov thread on ebob as well?!?!??!?!
I admit that my kids, when they were younger and me more naive, used to get ‘happy meals’ with prepackaged apples (I figured this was better than fries ). Upon opening, the smell was similar to that of prepacked baby carrots . . . . .
Did you attempt to return them to the grocery store only to be told:
" a lot of people mistake the term corked on potatoes for something naturally occurring like sulfur, while some may find this to be a flaw, it really isn’t something we can provide a refund for. The trouble is, people hear terms like corked when they don’t know what it really means. At our store, we are shocked if there are more than a handful or corked potatoes a year. Many potatoes, especially reds just need to open up. I’ll refund you this time, because you come in a lot, but we need to be careful about it in the future."
had a corked bottle of water once in a restaurant–it was so distinctive. Both the sommelier and I had never experienced that. The wine was fine, though!
alan