Thanks for putting this together and posting it for us to see!
1 Like
The prices quoted on a normally low-ball offer for the 2019 Vietti crus I just got seem to imply a ~20% price increase.
1 Like
Handful of comments from producers heard at La Festa suggests 2020 is likely ābetterā than 2019, and 2021 looks very promising, possibly the best of the three. Either way, sounds like 3 good vintages in a row coming our way after the (mostly) rough 2018s.
3 Likes
I will be curious to follow the trio of '19, '20, and '21 in Piedmont. In my early experience with these vintages in Langhe Nebbiolo Iāve preferred '19s to '20s. A few of the the entry level wines Iāve tried from '20 seem rather soft, while the '19s showed better structure. Of course, it may well be that the entry LNs arenāt representative in this feature and the Barolo vintage wonāt reflect the same character. Iāve tried a couple of '21s and though very young they seem to have a good balance of fruit and structure.
On the other hand, a recent Ar.Pe.Pe. '20 Rosso was excellent and may bode well for the vintage in Alto Piedmonte and Valtellina.
4 Likes
Speaking of Alto Piemonte and Valtellina, whatās your read on the '17 and '18 vintages?
Iām seeing '18s getting released in my local shops, but Iām a little concerned that they are flabby. However, I read elsewhere that '18 was a good vintage in the Alto Piemonte (maybe the altitude helped mitigate the heat?)
I thought it was Roberto Conterno who said 2018 was better in Alto Piemonte than in the Langhe.
Iāve not tasted those vintages extensively, but my (unoriginal!) take is that they are less prone to the excesses of heat in those two vintages than wines from the Langhe may be. Iāve enjoyed wines Iāve had from those regions in '17 and '18 more than I have those from the Langhe and would be more inclined to buy. Like you, Iāve also read several sources suggesting they are perhaps both very good vintages in Alto Piedmonte. Galloni seems to have scored many wines from the region well. Nothing too groundbreaking there, but many producers release these late and Iām still eyeing and buying '15s '16s and even some '13s from the region. Having said all of that, from a comparative standpoint Iāve found Vallanaās '16s were much better than the '18s. I have some of their '17 Boca but have it buried.
2 Likes
Well luckily for him he has wine from both regions to sell! And the price increased sharply on his Gattinara for the '18 vintage. It does seem that statement is likely true though.
1 Like
A lot of good information here. Count me in the camp of anticipating that I will enjoy the ā19 vintage more than ā20. The warm/dry weather trend in the Langhe, to me, has not been favorable for Nebbiolo as the alcohol trend line keeps climbing close to an uncomfortable level. When I read the ā19 vintage as cooler and more classically structured, then I will load up the truck for that. If I want sexy sweet red fruit, I will drink a Barbera.
1 Like
Thank you. I still am mainly seeing '15s and '16s, so have been doing the same type of buying as you (w/r/t Alto Piemonte and Valtellina), but some of the '18s are finally hitting my market. I may pick a couple up.
Your feedback is much appreciated!
1 Like
I hosted a blind tasting of 18s on Tuesday and found many disappointing. So, as much as I hate to admit it, Galloni may have been right.
I was hoping for a vintage like 2012, which I liked, but these werenāt as satisfying as the '12s were at the same stage. On the positive side, they were quite approachable.
The line-up was:
Fratelli Alessandria - Commune di Verduno
Oddero- normale (which included fruit from several crus they didnāt bottle separately in 2018)
Cavallotto- Bricco Boschi
Francesco Rinaldi - Cannubi
Giacomo Fennochio - Cannubi
Brezza - normale
Aldo Conterno- Bussia
Baudana - Baudana
Group favorites and mine: F Rinaldi, Baudana, Oddero (great value). I liked the Brezza, but the group put it 7th.
2 Likes
Yeah I think 2018 is the weakest vintage since perhaps 2009, based on what Iāve tasted.
At the La Festa masterclass, I thought the standout was the Vietti Cerequio, which to me remains the only wine Iāve tasted in 2018 thatās truly āgreatā. I donāt think its super complex, but itās got great density of fruit and the purity of the red fruit and floral notes are beautiful.
The Francesco Rinaldi Rocche dellāAnnunziata, Benevelli Mosconi, Giuseppe Rinaldi Brunate, Oddero Brunate, Castello di Verduno Massara, and Burlotto Monvigliero were also good to very good wines, in my opinion. At the going prices in the U.S., the Francesco Rinaldi Rocche seemed like the best buy. Iām also intrigued by the Castello di Verduno - my prior experience with them was a dirty, undrinkable 2010 Monvigliero. The Oddero normale is also really good in my experienceā¦they are doing great stuff at Oddero these days.
I guess reading my list of good to great wines above, it sounds more positive than āweakest vintage since 2009ā, but in a tasting of 15 wines from 2018 it becomes relative. When I tasted a 2014 Massolino Rionda and 2015 Conterno Arione the day after La Festa, it was immediately clear that those wines were in a different league than any of the 2018s, and next to those wines any of the '18s would have appeared diluted.
I know what you mean by dilution (Galloniās term). They seem to lack concentration.
The funny thing is, from what Iāve read (including the article Guillermo linked to at the top of this spread), there werenāt any heavy rains after early June. So, whatever the issue is, it isnāt the dilution you get from rain late in the season. Maybe the heavy growth on the vines, compensating for the stress in 2017?
Galloniās article talked about the likelihood that the stress of 2017 coupled with the wild weather in 2018, such as the huge rains in May & June, were an issue.
In terms of rain at the end of the season, Masnaghettiās overview of the vintage says that the weather forecasts called for rain the weekend of October 7, and a number of producers picked early because of that - the rains ended up not arriving that weekend, but this still had an effect of forcing an earlier pick. Not sure what % of producers did that. The Masnaghetti charts do show an above normal amount of rain in October.
Masnaghetti also mentions that it was unseasonally warm late in the season in September, and the fluctuations in temperature between day and night were minimal, which is bad for Nebbiolo.
It sounds like the vines were in a bad place to start the year, the middle of the season was a mess (literally, I guess with big rain storms) in terms of rain and mildew, and the end of the year lacked the conditions needed for good Nebbiolo, possibly coupled with a bit of rain or fear of rain in October impacting things.
Thatās interesting. Masnaghettiās account is a little different from the consorzioās summary of the vintage, which makes no mention of rain in October.
Over the years, Iāve found the consorzioās summaries pretty honest, mentioning setbacks, though stressing the positive somewhat, as one might expect. To quote:
[After the May-June heavy rains} Flowering and subsequent berry set took place regularly and in optimal climatic conditions, immediately suggesting that it would be a plentiful vintage, as proved to be the case following the closing up of the clusters of grapes. Green harvesting became necessary for nearly all varietals in order to curb production to within the limits provided for under the various production regulations. Development was gradual during the summer, with temperatures rising considerably from mid-July on, and a long period of constant fine weather helped the grapes to ripen without the harvest needing to be brought forward. ā¦
Dolcetto was the first red varietal to be picked, and it is showing an average sugar content, while the acidity is lower than in recent vintages, even though the levels of pH in the musts are as usual. This is due mainly to the ratio between the two main acid components: indeed, the malic acid degraded thanks to high daytime temperatures in late August-early September, while a good concentration was preserved in the grapes of the tartaric acid which formed early in the season when lower temperatures helped its synthesis. This phenomenon was also seen in the later-ripening red wine varietals.
ā¦ [T]he weather in September was good for the vines, contributing to the quality of the wines produced using medium-long vegetative cycle varietals, which were able to benefit to the full. As a matter of fact, the Nebbiolo grapes were ripe for harvesting as per tradition in early October, with picking operations taking around three weeks in all. Unlike the other varieties, Nebbiolo yields were limited, with certain situations in which there were few clusters in parts of vineyards.
Perhaps some of the wines reflect insufficient thinning/green harvesting, and/or the unusually low malic acids.
1 Like
John, I recall, maybe inaccurately, that the heavy rains in May and June caused a lot of mildew/disease in the vineyards, and there was an implication that many of the growers were not as diligent combatting it.
Speaking of the Consorzio, they limited access to the 2022 numbers to the press. I honestly think Wine Berserkers acts essentially as the press from a consumer perspective, especially in topics like this one. I think, as of this early point our predictions have held up and thereās value here.
Iām considering requesting press access for WB to keep this going (I forget who it was that got essentially press treatment at a couple of Bordeaux chateaus based on their WB posting so thereās precedent). Otherwise the four years of 2018-2021 may be the only ones we can do this exercise on.
You may be right about that. From the Consorzioās last sentence:
In conclusion, we can say that its has been a vintage in the traditional mould which demanded the attention of vinegrowers in their management of the vineyard in order to achieve results which were better than had been expected at the beginning of the campaign.
1 Like
Hi John,
Do you have notes from the tasting? What did you find very disappointing about the wines. What was Galloniās view?
Sorry if mentioned elsewhere I couldnāt find it in the thread. I am really curious to learn more about how the 2018s are showing.
Thank you
Not John, but Iām pretty sure there is a thread on Galloniās view on the 2018 vintage somewhere. Search Galloni and 18 and you should find it. To summarize my understanding though, itās that while there are some nice wines the vintage overall is not very successful. Comparatively dilute wines which may show early but arenāt for the long haul. While Iāve found some sources online claiming the vintage is better than that, they are mostly coming from sources with a vested interest in selling the wines. The views on this board seem to confirm that itās simply not a very good vintage. The only '18s I have are a few Fratelli Alessandria because the price was right, and I donāt plan to buy any more. Iād much rather backfill '16s where possible (and '15s and '13s and older when I see them), and keep my powder dry for the '19 through '21 vintages.