If you are arranging and buying, you can be specific. However you are asking folks, who may not be as “in to” wine as you are, to provide. So go with stuff that is WIDELY (like grocery store) available for their contribution. Let them have a bit of say-so rather than telling them to bring “cloudy bay”. Instead maybe ask for them to locate a SB with a particular style.
Either that or just provide the wines yourself and you get to have absolute control.
I like the fruit vs acid, steel vs oak, cats pee vs mineral discovery if you want to be geeky. But remember that you aren’t teaching a Learning Annex wine discovery class, so above all make sure it’s fun for all levels of wine snobbery.
In NZ I’d definitely consider an NZ classic example (of which there are many) vs. one of the more adventurous labels e.g. Cloudy Bay vs. their Te Koko, or Graywhacke vs. their Wild version. There are others that do both styles e.g. Te Mata
Perhaps then best to do similar with Sancerre, choosing two very different styles. If you have the glasses for it, then 2x2 flights allows a compare and contrast to say:
If they are experienced wine tasters, they’ll find a bunch of wines from one region more interesting.
If they are not, then one from each of four regions will be more fun and educational. Plus, less experienced tasters will more easily discern the difference than they would with four SBs from the same region.
One fun thing, if you want to splurge, would be to get one world class SB and serve it after the four bottle tasting. Open a Didier Dagueneau, Araujo or something else, sort of “we’ve just seen how four regular SB from around the world taste, now let’s look at one premium example and learn something from that.”
Sounds like fun. I personally would avoid a “ringer”. They tend to often finish first or last and that isn’t really a measure of quality as much as it is just different. This is an easy enough topic that you can find all that you want once you figure out the format. Stick to it and enjoy the process.
Depending on your audience, you might want to do a tasting from around the world and then later do region by region or just pick a region. Fwiw, my favorites are Francois or Pascal (two different winries from cousins IIRC) Cotat from the Loire.
One of the great things about SV Blanc is the price. Except for 1st growth Bordeaux, you can drink well around the world for $30 a bottle or less. I like the idea of an around the globe tasting, a couple from France, maybe Chili, definitely New Zealand, and California. Sounds like a fun time!
Very good advice. Tasting before and after is always very informative. Also agree on choosing low spice level dishes (such as pad thai) for this pairing.
The cat piss smell of most Sauv Blancs deter me from drinking much. Vatan Clos la Neore and the Von Winning I are two superb examples without the cat piss aroma.