TN: 2003 JJ Prum Wehlener Sohnenuhr Auslese - What happened?

WINE TALK
41

Russell,

I would prefer to understand their preferences with respect to style and I would like to see some discrimination with ratings. A case in point it has been Schloss Lieser 2016s line up which has been underwhelming in many of the new vineyards. I guess you were at the Auctions and probably not moved by the Doctor Spatlese (vis a vis peers and vis a vis previous Lieser auction wines). I would like to read that from a pro…

Just my 0.02c.

PF.

42

Seems like someone has an axe to grind.

43

I thought Liesers Doctor Spatlese was one of the wines of the auction. As did my party including one of (or the) UKs largest importers.

I don’t know your point really, MFW is a free newsletter. Yes there is a score compression, yes I know Jean and David so am both biased, and familiar with their tastes.