Alan, if you are going to buy an '87 you should really, really buy the Baraillon that they have. Vintage (1982) Domaine de Baraillon is the first serious brandy I ever tried back when a buddy of mine used to work at a wine bar. It is truly excellent stuff. I’ve had '82, '83, '84 and I believe '86, and each was excellent, but '87 is supposedly the best vintage of that run ('82 also strong I believe).
I’ve not had the Cardinat. They also have an '87 Jean-Bon. Last year I bought the '96 and '99 Jean-Bon and much preferred the '99. The '96 tasted a bit tired, so that would make me worry about the '87, but that could be vintage or bottle variation as well. In any case, they’re probably all quite nice, but I grabbed some '87 Baraillon and it took some self control not to buy several.
On a recent trip to France, I paid up for a fancy tour of Otard, and ended up buying a bottle of their Baron Otard 1972 Cognac Petite Champagne. I shared a glass with a friend the other day–astoundingly good stuff.
It isn’t life changing, but it is easy drinking and a tremendous value. These are perfect for scratching the casual cognac itch, I’m going to grab a few more.
Michael (if you see this), I did buy the 87, finally drinking it now. Honestly, it’s a bit too strong for my tastes. Now I’m wondering if it’s completely gauche to drop a bit of ice in for dilution. ABV says 43%, so not extremely high, but between the alc and a bit of rusticity, it’s a tough drink.
I am a big fan of the Tesseron Lot 29. Unfortunately, the prices has continued to increase. When I first bought it cost was $215 per bottle. It is now up over $600 in my market.
I bought a 1964 Leon Beyries “La Hauresse” Armagnac from K&L a few months ago (my wife’s birth year), and we opened it tonight. We like it a lot - very smooth with lots of creme brûlée, vanilla, chocolate, leather, and dried fruit, but our kids (19 and 25) gave mixed reviews:
Thing 1 (25): “I can smell the chocolate and vanilla, but also the rubbing alcohol.”
Thing 2 (19): “It smells like nail polish remover.”
A handful of years ago, Tesseron was fairly priced. Not sure if it was the Parker scores or what, but prices have taken off – which is a bummer as I really like the house.
Loaded up on a bunch L’Encantada Armagnacs awhile back, should last me a good while.