My version of reality is that Fu started the “it’s a thing” with his avatar of a bottle of Noon Eclipse being dumped back in the eBob days. ERP himself took offense to Charley’s avatar not long after making some kind of remark to the effect that he found the avatar disturbing and unfair.
Once in a blue moon, you hit a white Rhone at the right age where it’s a great experience. I had a Beaucastel Blanc once at maybe around that 15-20 year old age (it was maybe a mid 1990s vintage) and it was a beauty. But it’s the lowest batting average of any wine category, in my opinion and experience. It’s like the NL pitcher batting average.
For me, wine is about enjoyment and having an experience. If I’m not enjoying it…it’s just alcohol. I don’t really like being drunk, so down the drain, or strait to the garbage pale; it’s not something I plan to drink.
Sorry, if this is going to get a new competition “who put the most expensive/reknowned bottles down the drain” I will abandon any further discussion … I find that offputting …